Skip to main content
Skip to main content
Normal View Dyslexic View

Comment on: Prevention of incisional hernia with retrorectus synthetic mesh versus biological mesh following loop ileostomy closure (Preloop trial)

BJSA
BJS Academy
0000-0000
BJS Foundation Limited
London, UK
Correspondence to: Prof. Chengting Zheng, MD (email: just4hao@163.com)
Gastroenterology Disease Center
Chongqing University Three Gorges Hospital
Chongqing
China
_______
BJS, https://doi.org/10.1093/bjs/znad362, published 07 November 2023
_______
Dear Editor
We read the article by Makarainen et al.1, which makes a valuable contribution to understanding of the efficacy and safety of mesh use in this context. It is a well-designed investigation, however, we would like to raise a few methodological considerations regarding potential confounding factors that may influence the study's outcomes.
First, factors such as smoking, diabetes, preoperative immunosuppressive therapy, and preoperative radiotherapy2-4 are well-established risk factors for incisional hernia. Stratifying patients based on these factors would help mitigate their potential impact on the study results, particularly preoperative radiotherapy, which is commonly administered for rectal cancer. While we acknowledge that not all factors need to be stratified, we believe that these specific factors are critical and should be taken into account, as they can significantly influence the risk of incisional hernia. Even if stratification is not performed, we strongly recommend that future studies at least compare these factors between the two patient groups in the results section. This would provide a clearer and more convincing analysis of the study outcomes.
Second, we note a discrepancy in the mesh size between the synthetic and biological meshes used, with the synthetic mesh averaging 7.3 cm in width, compared with 5 cm for the biological mesh. This variation in size could affect the comparative outcomes5.
We believe that incorporating these factors, either through stratification, or detailed comparison in the results section, would strengthen the findings and enhance the clarity and robustness of the conclusions. This would contribute to a more accurate understanding of the relative efficacy and safety of synthetic versus biological mesh in preventing incisional hernia.
References
Makarainen EJ, Wiik HT, Kossi JAO, Pinta TM, Mantymaki LJ, Mattila AK et al. Prevention of incisional hernia with retrorectus synthetic mesh versus biological mesh following loop ileostomy closure (Preloop trial). BJS 2024;111: https://doi.org/10.1093/bjs/znad362.
Ishimoto Y, Otsuki Y, Nuri T and Ueda K. Abdominal Wall Incisional Hernia Repair with the Anterior Component Separation Technique and Reinforcement with an Anterior Rectus Abdominis Sheath Flap. Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open 2023;11:e5106.
Oprea V, Mardale S, Buia F, Gheorghescu D, Nica R, Zdroba S and Grad O. The influence of Transversus Abdominis Muscle Release (TAR) for complex incisional hernia repair on the intraabdominal pressure and pulmonary function. Hernia 2021;25:1601-1609.
Heimann TM, Swaminathan S, Greenstein AJ and Steinhagen RM. Incidence and Factors Correlating With Incisional Hernia Following Open Bowel Resection in Patients With Inflammatory Bowel Disease: A Review of 1000 Patients. Ann Surg 2018;267:532-536.
Kulacoglu H, Celasin H and Oztuna D. Individual mesh size for open anterior inguinal hernia repair: an anthropometric study in Turkish male patients. Hernia 2019;23:1229-1235.
Copied!