Skip to main content
Skip to main content
Normal View Dyslexic View

Author response: European Society of Coloproctology guidelines for the management of pilonidal disease

BJSA
BJS Academy
0000-0000
BJS Foundation Limited
London, UK
_______
BJS, https://doi.org/10.1093/bjs/znae237, published 14 October 2024
_______
Dear Editor
We thank the authors of the letter for their comments. The guideline group was appointed following AGREE -S principles of selection of appropriate stakeholders. Some have methodological experience, some experience in writing guidelines and some have clinical experience in dealing with pilonidal disease.
We thank the authors for identifying areas that they disagree with. However, we again draw their attention to the rigorous process used to assess the literature. Any inconsistencies (eg a definition of recurrence) reflect the inconsistencies that are found in the literature. As the literature is generally so poor, 'speculation', or expert opinion is a common theme throughout the guidelines. Authors (and Editors) that perpetuate this poor standard are recommended to reflect on this before publishing yet one more single centre cohort study.
In addition to a careful assessment of the literature according to the AGREE -S principles with selection of the highest quality research, the process followed included a conflict of interest assessment.
Yours sincerely
The Executive Committee of the ESCP Pilonidal Guidelines
Copied!