Skip to main content
Skip to main content
Normal View Dyslexic View

Author response: Prevention of incisional hernia with retrorectus synthetic mesh versus biological mesh following loop ileostomy closure (Preloop trial)

BJSA
BJS Academy
0000-0000
BJS Foundation Limited
London, UK
Correspondence to: Elisa J Mäkäräinen (e-mail: elisa.makarainen@pohde.fi)
Department of surgery
Medical Research Centre Oulu
PL29
90029 OYS
OULU
Finland
_______
BJS, https://doi.org/10.1093/bjs/znad362, published 07 November 2023
_______
Dear Editor
First, we would like to thank you for your interest and comments on the Preloop trial.
We agree that designing a study like this should include factors influencing the incidence of incisional hernia. As the Preloop trial was conceived as a pilot study to determine whether a synthetic mesh can safely be used during loop ileostomy closure, it was not possible to stratify well-known risk factors. However, these are acknowledged in the manuscript, and no significant differences in their prevalence were observed between the groups.
We also agree that, in an ideal scenario, the meshes would have been of the same size. However, since the cost of biological mesh increases proportionally with size, the chosen dimensions (5x10 cm) reflect what is most likely to be used in real-world clinical practice. Importantly, the size of the mesh did not appear to influence the likelihood of hernia formation, as Incisional hernia rates were low in both groups.
Based on the results of the Preloop trial, synthetic mesh should be further investigated for hernia prevention even in contaminated surgical sites.
Copied!